Seth Godin has a though-provoking post (as usual) on elites, which offers me a nice segue into my own thoughts on this curiously reviled segment of society.
If you listen to Rush Limbaugh, Glenn Beck and the self-described Tea Partiers in the US (and really, I hope you don't), you'd think that "the elites" are destroying the country. The President is an elite because he went to Harvard (but curiously Bush wasn't an elite for going to Yale) and government in general is filled to the rafters with elites ruining all the goodness and apple pie average Joes like Sarah Palin have contributed to the American way of life.
The truth is "elite" has more or less simply become a replacement for the last bogey-man word conservatives were so successful at manipulating: "liberal." Remember when everything bad in the world was caused by liberals? Well liberals finally got smart in the US (it took them 30 years) and started calling themselves "progressives." And dang, it's way harder to rail against progress, so right-wingers had to find another in. Bring in the elites.
The disconnect is, in every other walk of life, being an elite is what we strive for. Our sports heroes are elite athletes. Our army (we hope) comprises elite fighting forces. The scientists who discover cures for the diseases that ail us are elite doctors. And thank God, don't you think?
Yet somehow, the half-governor of Alaska and others would have you believe that we don't need elites in government. Better to send to Washington that guy who's never read a book or the one who still believes evolution is a "theory" (you know, like the one about the earth being round). Better to elect an underachiever with zero curiosity or desire to better himself. (Dubya much?)
I think those who revile elites ought to really be speaking out against "elitism." You know, like when you believe you deserve more than the next guy because you're better, smarter, more powerful than he is? You know, like on Wall Street and in the C-suite of many corporations.
"I'm here at the top so you work your ass off and I'll collect my bonus check. Thanks peons."
That's elitism and, the fact is, it's not linked to liberals or progressives or smart hard-working people with the best of intentions in government or science or the military. It's part and parcel of the conservative philosophy, in part handed down by Ronald Reagan, which makes the wealthy believe they're entitled to be even richer because they somehow worked harder than the little guy.
That's not what elites believe, it's what elitists believe. There's a big difference. And it's time someone tells Palin -- or at least draws her a picture with crayons. (Okay, that was sort of elitist. My bad.)
Recent Comments